eBay Scams: 12 Types Every Buyer and Seller Should Know
eBay processes over $70 billion in gross merchandise volume annually. Its auction format, buyer-seller messaging, and global reach create fraud opportunities that do not exist on other platforms. Both buyers and sellers are targets. Here are 12 scams every eBay user should recognize.
Buyer Scams
1. Photo-Only Listings. The listing title says "iPhone 15 Pro Max" but buried in the description is the phrase "listing is for the photo/box only." Buyers who do not read the full description pay $800+ for an empty box or a printed photograph. While technically disclosed, these listings are designed to deceive.
"Apple iPhone 15 Pro Max 256GB — READ DESCRIPTION — This listing is for the ORIGINAL BOX ONLY. Phone is not included." — Actual listing with a title and photos designed to mislead.
2. Counterfeit Items. Branded goods — watches, sneakers, electronics, luxury accessories — listed as authentic that are actually counterfeits. eBay's authenticity guarantee covers some categories, but many counterfeit listings fall outside its scope.
3. Shill Bidding. The seller uses alternate accounts to place fake bids on their own auctions, artificially driving up the price. The legitimate buyer ends up paying more than market value because they were bidding against phantom competitors.
4. Bait and Switch. The listing shows photos of a high-quality item, but the delivered product is a lower-quality version, a different model, or a refurbished item sold as new. The seller counts on buyers not bothering with returns for minor discrepancies.
5. Fake Tracking Numbers. Similar to the Amazon scam: the seller provides a tracking number that shows delivery, but the package was sent to a different address in your area. eBay's automated dispute system sees "delivered" and sides with the seller.
Think it might be a scam?
Paste it here for a free, instant verdict.
Free · No signup required · Cmd+Enter to scan
6. Off-Platform Communication. After winning an auction, you receive a message asking to complete payment outside eBay — through wire transfer, cash apps, or cryptocurrency. This removes eBay's buyer protection entirely.
Seller Scams
7. Return Fraud. A buyer purchases an item, swaps it with a broken or counterfeit version, and returns the swap for a full refund. The seller receives their own damaged product back while the buyer keeps the legitimate one. Electronics and luxury goods are frequent targets.
8. "Not as Described" Abuse. The buyer claims the item was "significantly not as described" to force a return with free return shipping, even when the item was exactly as listed. Some buyers do this serially to get temporary free use of products.
9. Fake Payment Notifications. Sellers receive emails that appear to be from PayPal or eBay confirming payment. The email is fake — no actual payment was made. The seller ships the item based on the fake confirmation and loses both the product and the money.
"You've received a payment of $749.00 from buyer. The funds are being held and will be released once you provide a shipping tracking number. Please ship the item immediately." — Fake PayPal email with no corresponding actual transaction.
10. Overpayment Scam. A buyer "accidentally" overpays and asks the seller to refund the difference. The original payment is made with a stolen credit card or fraudulent account. After the seller refunds the "overpayment," the original fraudulent payment is reversed, leaving the seller out of both the product and the refunded amount.
11. Shipping Address Change. After payment, the buyer asks the seller to ship to a different address than the one on the eBay order. If the seller complies and the buyer later files a dispute, eBay's protection only covers shipments to the address on file. The seller loses the dispute.
12. Empty Box Claim. The buyer receives the item but claims the box was empty or contained rocks/filler. Without video evidence of packing and shipping, the seller cannot prove the item was in the box. This is especially common with high-value electronics.
How to Protect Yourself as a Buyer
Read the full listing description. Do not buy based on title and photos alone. Look for disclaimers like "box only," "for parts," or "as-is."
Check seller ratings and history. Look at the number of transactions, the percentage of positive feedback, and recent feedback comments. A seller with 99.5% positive over 5,000 transactions is far safer than a new account with 3 ratings.
Pay through eBay's system only. Never send money outside the platform. eBay's Money Back Guarantee only applies to transactions completed through eBay.
Document everything. Save screenshots of the listing, photos, and description at the time of purchase. Listings can be edited after sale.
How to Protect Yourself as a Seller
Verify payments independently. Log into your PayPal or eBay Payments account directly to confirm payment — do not rely on email notifications.
Ship only to the address on the order. Never change the shipping address based on buyer requests after payment.
Video-record packing and shipping. For high-value items, film yourself packing the item and handing it to the carrier. This evidence is critical for empty-box disputes.
Require signature confirmation. For items over $750, eBay requires signature confirmation for seller protection. Use it for all valuable shipments.
If you encounter a suspicious eBay listing, message, or payment notification, verify it at IsThisAScam before proceeding.
Received something suspicious? Check it now for free →